Play Your Best Golf - Always.

Struggling with poor or inconsistent performance; or with pain?

Discover improvement through the science-based approach of a Ph.D. in kinesiology

Book Your Lesson Now

The x-factor in golf is the difference between how far your shoulders and hips turn at the top of the backswing. For decades, coaches have taught it as a secret to distance. However, a closer look at human movement shows the idea is not as solid as it sounds. This guide explains what the x-factor is, where it came from, why the research doesn’t back it up, and what to focus on instead.

Start Here: Every Golf Swing Is Human Movement

All human movement happens when muscles act across joints to move skeletal segments (bones). The golf swing is no exception. For more on how the body produces motion, see this overview of biomechanics.

Here is a simple example. The biceps muscle crosses the elbow. When your brain signals it to contract, it shortens and pulls the forearm toward the upper arm. As a result, the elbow bends.

Therefore, the key question is which muscles move which joints, and in which directions. Everything else follows from that. Swing plane, an across-the-line shaft, an open clubface and even the grip pressure are all results of body movement. The club cannot move by itself like a magic wand.

What Is the X-Factor in Golf?

In 1992, George Peper, longtime editor of Golf Magazine, introduced the x-factor to a golf world hungry for ball-striking help. He wrote, “Millions of words have been written about how to hit a golf ball. It’s rare, therefore, to come across a completely original contribution to the wisdom of instruction, but that is exactly what Jim McLean has produced in the X-factor. With the assistance of Sportsense swing computers, McLean has done beyond mere theory and shown actual proof of a more powerful way to swing.” [see http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DE8ODf3IeAU]

The x-factor definition

According to its discoverer, Jim McLean, the x-factor is the “gap” or “differential” between hip turn and shoulder turn at the top of the backswing. In his words, it “creates explosion going forward.” In short, a bigger gap was said to mean a more powerful swing.

Screen shot 2013-08-22 at 3.16.08 PM

Where the idea came from

The discovery rested on one observation. The five longest hitters on the PGA Tour showed a much larger x-factor than the five shortest hitters. Consequently, the golf world embraced the concept almost overnight.

How the Golf World Reacted to the X-Factor

Fitness professionals began to talk about thoracic-lumbar dissociation and how they could help golfers achieve it. In addition, tons of research money went into studying the x-factor. To see how many scientists took part, and to read Professor Kwon’s study (head biomechanist at Texas Woman’s University) and his debunking of the subject, see http://50.87.35.246/~chriscq7/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/X-Factor-paper.pdf

Questions Nobody Asked About the X-Factor Theory

Why did no one first test the idea against simple body-movement capabilities and basic physics? Several questions deserve an answer.

  • Is the movement a true differential between hips and shoulders?
  • Is it desirable for golfers, both for efficiency and for injury risk?
  • Could something else deliver the same benefit?

Correlation or causation?

Did anyone ask whether the x-factor was correlation or causation? Perhaps the long hitters simply had better overall flexibility. Alternatively, the x-factor itself may have caused the extra distance. Those are very different conclusions. The classic problem is explained in this article on why correlation does not imply causation.

Tour players are not always efficient movers

Moreover, the moves PGA Tour players make are not necessarily the most efficient human movements. They may simply be a lucky way their brains and bodies found to reach the ball correctly, despite non-ideal joint positions in the backswing.

Screen shot 2013-08-22 at 3.14.19 PM

How to Get Into an X-Factor Position in Seconds

You can reach an x-factor position as easily as John Daly, who has one of the biggest. You may not want to by the end of this article, though. Try it yourself:

  1. Set up normally. Take your regular address position with the club.
  2. Bend the lead side. Flex the lead knee, hip and shoulder (left side for a right-handed golfer).
  3. Notice the trail shoulder. When the lead shoulder drops forward, the trail shoulder must go backward. You are now in an “x-factor” position.

That backward shoulder movement is being mistaken for rotation. In reality, it is only lateral flexion of the lead side of the trunk, plus hip and knee flexion and ankle extension.

Why Separating Hips and Shoulders Raises Problems

The mobile-stable joint model

The Titleist Performance Institute (TPI), among other golf fitness groups, recommends alternating stable and mobile joints. It calls the thoracic spine (mid-back) an area that must be made “mobile” through fitness or other interventions. The segments directly above and below, the lumbar and cervical spines, are treated as “stable.”

Ironically, the neck has the most muscles and the widest range of motion in many directions. The thoracic spine, by contrast, is a fairly rigid region with a giant rib cage attached. So which basic human movement needs the cumbersome rib-cage joints to rotate while the neck and lower back stay still?

Muscles cannot twist one spinal segment alone

Imagine rotating one section of the spine against another. The spine has very small rotational muscles. Most whole-body rotation comes from the abdominal muscles. They cannot be asked to turn only vertebrae 8 to 19 from the top and no others.

Expect inefficient ball striking and a greater risk of injury.

A Better Coil: Rotate the Body as One Unit

To make an efficient coil in the backswing, the whole body must rotate as one unit, from the ankles to the top of the head. The neck and shoulder area is far more mobile than the hips or legs, especially with the feet planted. Because of that, the shoulder-to-hip turn proportions stay consistent. This is especially true in a Minimalist Golf Swing. It removes the body’s ability to over- or under-twist any part during the backswing, because the required rotation is completed before the swing starts. As a result, no confounding rotation, correct or incorrect, happens on the way back.

If you want help turning this into real distance, explore elite golf performance coaching or start with a golf performance assessment. For another example of a swing term that confuses players, read about the cosine factor. Likewise, putting better follows the same movement-first thinking.

X-Factor vs. X-Factor Stretch

The x-factor stretch is a different animal. It is powerful and easy to acquire, and it needs no x-factor at all. For golfers of any skill level, it comes naturally from the Minimalist Golf Swing.

X-Factor in Golf: Frequently Asked Questions

What is the x-factor in golf?

It is the gap between hip turn and shoulder turn at the top of the backswing. Jim McLean introduced it in 1992.

Who discovered the x-factor?

Teacher Jim McLean discovered it. He used Sportsense swing computers and found that the longest PGA Tour hitters showed a larger gap.

Does a bigger x-factor really add distance?

Not necessarily. The original finding showed correlation, not causation. Professor Kwon’s research challenged the theory.

Is the x-factor safe for your back?

Trying to twist one spinal section against another is inefficient. It also raises the scope for injury, because the spine’s rotational muscles are small.

What is the difference between the x-factor and the x-factor stretch?

The x-factor is a static gap at the top of the backswing. The x-factor stretch is a different, easier-to-acquire effect that the Minimalist Golf Swing creates without needing that gap.


Conclusion: What to Take Away From the X-Factor Debate

The x-factor started as a clever observation about long hitters. However, it confuses correlation with causation. It also ignores how the spine and muscles actually move. What looks like a hip-shoulder gap is mostly lateral flexion of the lead side. Instead of chasing a bigger x-factor, rotate the body as one efficient unit and aim for the x-factor stretch through a Minimalist Golf Swing. That approach is simpler, safer and easier to repeat.

Add to Preferred Sources

One reply on “Debunking Golf Myths 1 – The X-Factor”

  1. I am not taking one side or the other on the X-factor. I will share that back in about 96, the Acadamy I worked at had an x-factor training tool; its harnesses allowed for the measurent of the X-factor. I was told they stopped using it because the players who tried to attain PGA averages dropped off the planet. Their games suffered. I am sure there are many ways to look at this, but I opted to emphasize balance and use position as a reference point.

Comments are closed.